- Thermal limitations in electric motors affect their continuous output capability.
- Direct cooling technology can enhance motor performance by eliminating thermal bottlenecks.
- This technology allows for more flexible motor designs that can be optimized for specific applications.
- Direct cooling also improves long-term reliability and reduces maintenance needs for motors.
In the latest episode of Lex i con, we spoke with Dynamic E-Flow's Chief Technology Officer Manuel Hartong, who provided an in-depth analysis of the performance gaps in electric motors and their significance. Electric motors are known for their efficiency and reliability and are widely used in industries such as automotive and aerospace. However, as Hartong pointed out, there remains a fundamental limitation: heat.
While electric motors are highly efficient, they are not without flaws. The heat generated by copper windings must be managed. "Many electrical insulation materials are also thermal insulators," Hartong told us. In traditional designs, heat must pass through multiple layers of insulation, structural materials, and air gaps before reaching the cooling system. Damage occurs in this process. "Typically, to cool the motor, a water-cooling jacket is added around it. But there are many layers between the wires and the cooling medium," he explained. This creates a fundamental limitation. Motors can provide high peak power for a short time, but only for brief bursts.
"A typical automotive motor can run at peak power for 30 seconds, at most one minute," he stated. After that, output must be reduced. This limitation is particularly critical for applications such as electric aircraft. "If you imagine an airplane taking off, the time required must exceed that duration," he added.
The Inefficiency of Cooling Methods
The importance of cooling methods cannot be overlooked. To address this issue, most cooling systems focus on removing heat from the entire motor. However, Hartong believes this is fundamentally inefficient. "Cooling the motor instead of the heat source is like trying to extinguish a fire by cooling the room," he explained. This is a simple analogy but aptly captures the essence of the problem. Heat is generated in the windings, but most cooling systems only interact with the external structure. The longer the thermal pathway, the greater the resistance, and the higher the internal temperature. This is precisely why Dynamic E-Flow is taking a different approach.
Hartong and his team believe the focus should be on directly cooling the windings rather than the area around the motor. Their solution replaces traditional solid conductors with hollow conductors, allowing the coolant to flow through the wire itself. "The wire itself is a hollow structure, and the coolant is in direct contact with the copper," he said. This way, heat is removed precisely where it is generated, eliminating the thermal bottleneck. "If you remove heat from the wire, there will be no such peak performance limitation," he added. The result is a motor that behaves entirely differently from traditional designs. "With direct cooling, there is no difference between peak power and continuous power; they are the same," he said.
Advantages of Direct Cooling
One of the most immediate impacts of direct cooling is the ability to push current density beyond traditional limits. Due to thermal considerations, conventional motors typically operate within a limited range. Once this limitation is removed, new possibilities arise. "We're not talking about some percentage. We're talking about half the size or two to three times the power," he told us. This leap in power density opens the door to entirely new system architectures. Motors can be smaller, lighter, and more responsive, or they can provide significantly higher output within the same space. For industries such as aerospace, weight directly impacts cost and capability, making this a profound effect.
"If you halve the weight, you can carry more passengers," he added.
Perhaps the most interesting aspect of Hartong's work lies not only in the performance improvements but also in the shift in how engineers think about design. "If you remove the thermal limitations, you can design motors in a completely different way," he said. In traditional motor design, thermal limitations are a dominant factor. Engineers must constantly balance performance with heat. Once this limitation is removed, the design space expands significantly. "You are no longer designing around heat; you are designing around the application," he added. This freedom leads to unconventional yet highly effective solutions. In some cases, efficiency may be deliberately sacrificed to achieve other goals.
"You can intentionally make the motor less efficient just to make it smaller and lighter," he explained. This is a counterintuitive idea but reflects a more systematic engineering mindset.
While electric aviation is an obvious beneficiary, Hartong highlighted several other industries where direct cooling could have an immediate impact. Marine systems are a typical example. Large vessels rely on massive generators and motors that are often difficult or impossible to remove for maintenance. "Large generators on ships are often not removable and must be cut out," he said. Therefore, by reducing size and improving modularity, direct cooling can change how these systems are maintained. "If you make it smaller, you can actually take it out, maintain it, and reinstall it," he added.
Industrial applications, particularly those requiring sustained high power, will also benefit. Unlike passenger vehicles that rely on brief peak power, systems such as trucks, ships, and test benches require continuous output. "For industrial applications, you need power for extended periods," he stated.
Improving Reliability and Maintenance Needs
In addition to performance, direct cooling also addresses another critical issue in electric machinery: long-term reliability. "Thermal cycling is one of the main causes of motor failure," he said. Repeated heating and cooling cause materials to expand and contract, gradually degrading the integrity of insulation and structure. By strictly controlling temperature, these effects can be significantly reduced. "If you strictly control temperature, you can significantly increase lifespan," he stated. Hartong noted that traditional motors operate at around 356°F (180 degrees Celsius), while direct cooling systems can provide higher performance at lower temperatures.
"Our motors typically operate at a maximum temperature of about 120 degrees under higher power," he added. This reduction in thermal stress not only enhances reliability but also decreases maintenance needs over time. "You can design from a completely different level," he said.
Potential Impact of Direct Cooling Technology
The emergence of direct cooling technology represents a significant transformation in the design and performance of electric motors. The thermal limitations faced by traditional motors affect their continuous output, while direct cooling technology effectively addresses this issue. This not only enhances the power density of motors but also allows designers to optimize for specific applications with greater flexibility. Additionally, reducing thermal cycling damage to materials will help improve the long-term reliability of motors, thereby lowering maintenance needs, which has far-reaching implications for applications across various industries.

