AI Assistants Face Verification Barriers and Security Risks in Online Shopping

·by Henderson·AI
AI Assistants Face Verification Barriers and Security Risks in Online Shopping

An AI agent can handle your shopping until a website requires it to prove it is human. This is the issue faced by Meta's Muse at Walmart, the company's retail partner, which stated that these verification checks are not intended to block the assistant. According to a report from TechCrunch, Amazon is more direct, intentionally blocking the tool from shopping on its site. The appeal of personal AI agents like Meta's Muse lies in their ability to browse websites, fill shopping carts, and book travel, rather than just providing suggestions and leaving the rest to users.

However, having an authorized agent act on your behalf does not mean the website has agreed to transact with it. Some restrictions are intentionally set, while others stem from security systems that cannot reliably distinguish between legitimate agents and unnecessary automated traffic. In any case, you may still end up having to return to the keyboard to complete tasks you hoped to avoid.

Challenges and Limitations of AI Agents in Shopping

When it comes to money, security is a bigger concern. During JPMorgan Chase's earnings call in October, CFO Jeremy Barnum stated that some agents use shared login credentials and screen scraping to transfer funds, methods he described as "unsafe." The bank seeks to block these methods whenever possible, with Barnum warning that customers could be held responsible for unnecessary actions taken by agents if they hand over their credentials. Erroneous shopping orders are already troublesome enough, while unauthorized bank transfers present a different kind of headache.

Amazon is also battling with Perplexity over its Comet AI browser. The retailer argues that the agent violates its access rules and puts customer data at risk, while Perplexity insists its users have authorized it to act. A federal appeals court lifted a preliminary injunction against Perplexity in August 2026, although the underlying dispute remains unresolved. Additionally, there is an interesting situation: Amazon has its own "Buy for Me" feature that can purchase products from other brands' websites. Businesses also have commercial reasons to control automated access.

How Companies Are Addressing the Challenges of Automated Access

eBay's user agreement prohibits unauthorized purchasing agents unless the company grants permission. Delta told TechCrunch that its website does not integrate third-party agents for booking flights, although the airline did not confirm whether it intentionally blocks specific agents. Walmart's experience shows that blocked agents are not necessarily the result of intentional bans. Human verification prompts can interrupt automated shopping sessions, and Zillow also acknowledges that its anti-scraping defenses sometimes capture agents that should be allowed. From the user's perspective, both may appear as assistants that are unable to complete tasks.

Anyone who has browsed through a VPN may recognize this routine. Google explains that traffic from shared VPN networks can trigger reCAPTCHA challenges during similar automated activities. AI agents may encounter similar checks while browsing websites, even if they are following someone's instructions. Enabling a VPN does not magically override a website's restrictions on automated access. Cloudflare previously introduced controls for AI web crawlers, now allowing website owners to distinguish between search crawlers, AI training bots, and agents acting on behalf of users.

Since September 15, new domains using Cloudflare default to allowing search crawlers while blocking the use of AI training bots and agents on pages displaying advertisements. Website owners can adjust these rules, so a site blocking AI training bots is not necessarily rejecting an assistant attempting to make a purchase.

Other platforms have taken a more controlled approach. Shopify's checkout tool allows compatible browser agents to update checkout details and submit orders after buyer confirmation, returning control to shoppers for necessary verification steps.

H
About the author
Henderson